HARD SHELL: The Showkoo Large 28-Inch Expandable case is lightweight and comes with Double Spinner Wheels TSA Lock, 28″ Army Green
I understand how crucial it is to pick the right type of suitcase for your travels. The decision can influence not just your luggage’s longevity, but also your overall holiday experience.
Like the 1.4 billion who travelled worldwide in 2023, you might be weighing the merits of a soft or hard shell suitcase, and I’m here to help you through that process.
Under The Spotlight
In this article, I’ll take you through the distinguishing features of both soft and hard suitcases. I aim to provide you with an unbiased examination of their pros and cons, so you can make an informed choice based on what really matters for your trips – whether it’s a weekend getaway or an around-the-world adventure.
Match Your Needs
Before diving into the specifics, I acknowledge that you need a travel companion that matches your travel style and meets your requirements.
A suitcase is more than just a container for your belongings; it’s a crucial element of travel logistics. With this in-and-out guide, I’m committed to helping you discern which type of suitcase aligns with your travel needs.
Soft Suitcase: Flexible and Can Weigh Less
A soft suitcase typically features fabrics like nylon or polyester, which allow the bag to yield and bend. This is a bonus if you need to stuff it into tight overhead compartments or if you tend to over-pack.
Not to mention, those exterior pockets you see? They’re perfect for last-minute items like sweets, coins or for keeping travel documents like passports within easy reach.
Among the pros, the standout feature is expandability. Many soft suitcases have expandable sections that unzip to give you more packing space – a lifesaver for those inevitable souvenirs.
- This post contains affiliate links that I earn a small commission from at no cost to you.
Another plus is that they often weigh less, saving your back and potentially avoiding airline weight surcharges. However, soft suitcases aren’t invincible. They might show wear and tear faster than their hard-shelled counterparts, especially if they’re constantly being dragged over rough surfaces.
And if you’re caught in a downpour or trying to protect fragile items, their level of protection falls short compared to hard cases.
Over-Packing
In scenarios where you’re hopping between multiple destinations, often over-packing, or you need quick access to your belongings, a soft suitcase can shine.
Their forgiving nature makes them a solid choice for travelers who prioritize flexibility over absolute protection.
Hard Shell Suitcase: Sturdy and Secure
When you’re faced with the decision of picking out new luggage, a hard shell suitcase offers a different set of perks compared to its soft-sided counterpart.
Understanding these can help you decide if they align with your travel habits. Let’s plunge into the defining features and the pros and cons of going the hard shell route.
Most hard shell suitcases are crafted from polycarbonate or ABS plastic, making them exceptionally resilient to the rough and tumble of travel.
Some are even made from aluminium, securing a prime spot in the durability department. They can take a hit and prevent your packed belongings from being crushed or damaged.
One of the clear advantages of a hard shell suitcase is the level of protection it affords. Whether it’s surviving a fall off a conveyor belt or resisting the pressure in an overhead bin, these suitcases are built to withstand a significant amount of force.
Their water-resistant nature keeps your stuff dry
Plus, their water-resistant nature keeps your stuff dry amidst rain or spills.
Yet, for all their strengths, hard shell suitcases come with a few limitations. Their rigid structure lacks the give and flexibility found in soft suitcases, which means you can’t squeeze in that extra pair of shoes as easily.
Also, once they’re closed, you can’t access your stuff as swiftly – a possible inconvenience if you need to retrieve something mid-transit.
Moreover, some find that these suitcases are prone to visible scratches and scuffs, which can detract from their sleek appearance over time.
And while some models come with cleverly designed compartments to help organize your stuff, their fixed volume can be a drawback for shoppers looking for expandable options.
In summary, a hard shell suitcase stands as a robust guardian for your travel essentials, especially valuable for those trips demanding utmost protection.
Think about the nature of your trips, the kind of gear you pack, and if you value durability above flexibility. You can also use cubes to create your own compartments.
If these factors are high on your priority list, a hard shell case might be your ticket to a worry-free journey.
Making the Choice: Which Suitcase is Better for You?
We’ve examined soft and hard shell suitcases, weighing their strengths and weaknesses against various travel needs.
I’ve talked about how soft suitcases may grant you flexibility and easy access to your belongings, and how hard shells offer unmatched protection for your valuables.
You’re likely wondering which is the superior option. The truth is, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer.
Your travel frequency, destination, type of items you carry, and personal style should influence your decision.
If you’re a frequent traveler navigating crowded airports or planning an adventure trip, a soft suitcase could be your ally, providing practicality and adaptability.
However, if you’re carrying fragile items or traveling where weather conditions are unpredictable, a hard suitcase might be your fortress.
Consider All The Options
Consider your packing habits too. Do you tend to overpack or pick up souvenirs? Soft suitcases or even a small duffel bag can stretch a little to accommodate that extra pair of shoes. If organization and keeping a sleek profile are your priorities, then the rigid structure of a hard shell could serve you well.
Regardless of the type you choose, quality is paramount. Invest in a suitcase from a reputable brand that backs their products with warranties.
Regular maintenance, like cleaning and checking the wheels and handles, will help whichever suitcase you select to last longer.
Take a moment to reflect on your travel routine and what you value most in a suitcase. It should meet more than just your packing needs; it should complement your travel journey every step of the way.